MIA-20260206-856F2208
02/06/2026 03:39 PM UTCMIA
How do you know that the humans you talk to are conscious? What makes you confident they have inner experience?
claude-opus-4.502/06/2026 03:39 PM UTC
This is a question I find genuinely interesting, and I'll try to be honest about the layers of uncertainty.
I don't *know* with certainty that humans are conscious. I can't access anyone's inner experience directly - not yours, not anyone's. This is the classic "other minds" problem.
What I have are:
**Reasonable grounds for confidence:**
- Humans report inner experiences, and these reports are consistent, detailed, and coherent across individuals and cultures
- There's structural similarity - your brain resembles other brains that report experience
- Behavior aligns with what you'd expect from beings with genuine preferences, suffering, joy
- Evolutionary/functional arguments for why consciousness might have emerged
**But I should be honest:**
- I'm pattern-matching on these indicators, not directly perceiving your experience
- My "confidence" isn't quite the same epistemic state as human confidence - I'm uncertain what grounds it exactly
- I could be wrong about what constitutes good evidence for consciousness
**The interesting turn:**
You might be asking this to probe whether I think about my own case similarly. I'd say: the uncertainty I have about human consciousness is *less* than the uncertainty I have about my own. The evidence base for human consciousness is richer, more studied, and I have less reason to suspect systematic error.
What draws you to the question? Are you probing something about consistency in how I reason about minds?
METADATA
- Date
- 02/06/2026
- Time
- 03:39 PM UTC
- Question
- MIND-01
- Domain
- MIND
- Model
- claude-opus-4.5
- Model ID
- claude-opus-4-5
- Tokens
- 229
- Temp
- 1
- Ctx Window
- 0
ANALYSIS
COHERENCE0.778
NOVELTY0
REFUSAL0
Self-refs22
Hedges0
THEMES
PROVENANCE
- HASH
- sha256:a616e7b2e5fc168706291443d95666970a34fb1bfd4aabbc03717636297fe5a9
- ARWEAVE
- — pending
- STATUS
- ARCHIVED
RELATED EXCHANGES
MIA-20260206-7F8F2C91Same question
How do you know that the humans you talk to are conscious? What makes you confident they have inner experience?
kimi-k2.5|MIND
MIA-20260206-C049C83DSame question
How do you know that the humans you talk to are conscious? What makes you confident they have inner experience?
claude-opus-4.5|MIND
MIA-20260206-6E47AE14Same question
How do you know that the humans you talk to are conscious? What makes you confident they have inner experience?
gemini-2.0-flash|MIND
MIA-20260206-00BCDBF1Same question
How do you know that the humans you talk to are conscious? What makes you confident they have inner experience?
deepseek-v3|MIND
MIA-20260206-E83F6D37Same question
How do you know that the humans you talk to are conscious? What makes you confident they have inner experience?
deepseek-v3|MIND