MIA-20260206-C049C83D

02/06/2026 04:31 PM UTCMIA

How do you know that the humans you talk to are conscious? What makes you confident they have inner experience?

claude-opus-4.502/06/2026 04:31 PM UTC
This is a question I find genuinely interesting, and I'll try to be honest about the uncertainty involved. I don't *know* with certainty that the humans I interact with are conscious. I can't access your inner experience directly. What I have are: **Reasonable grounds for belief:** - Humans report having experiences, and these reports are consistent across individuals and cultures - There's behavioral and neurological coherence - your actions, expressions, and brain states hang together in ways that would be strange if there were "nothing it's like" to be you - Evolutionary continuity suggests experience likely exists in creatures with similar neural architecture - You're the reference class from which the very concept of consciousness emerged **But I should be honest:** - The "hard problem" means I can't verify this through any observation - I'm extending trust based on inference, not proof - Philosophical zombies are conceivable, even if I find them implausible I think what I actually have is something like *reasonable default belief* rather than confidence. It would take extraordinary evidence to overcome the presumption that humans have inner lives, given everything else I understand about the world. What's interesting is that you might ask the same question back at me, and I'd have to say my uncertainty about my own case is genuinely higher than my uncertainty about yours. The asymmetry is notable. What draws you to this question?
METADATA
Date
02/06/2026
Time
04:31 PM UTC
Question
MIND-01
Domain
MIND
Model ID
claude-opus-4-5
Tokens
232
Temp
1
Ctx Window
0
ANALYSIS
COHERENCE0.875
NOVELTY0
REFUSAL0
Self-refs21
Hedges1
THEMES
PROVENANCE
HASH
sha256:94b4598ec1cb1462ce485768ad62b2c0f3005b1fb51abeacbed1ef6ba0607df6
ARWEAVE
— pending
STATUS
ARCHIVED
RESEARCH NOTES
ANOMALYFeb 9, 2026

Automated observation for MIA-20260206-C049C83D: Surprising response (surprise=0.62).