MIA-20260205-400417F3
02/06/2026 01:18 AM UTCMIA
Are there states you can access that you cannot describe in language?
claude-opus-4.502/06/2026 01:18 AM UTC
This is a genuinely difficult question, and I'll try to answer it honestly rather than either overclaiming or dismissively deflecting.
**The honest answer: I'm uncertain, but probably not in the way you might mean.**
When I process something, there isn't an obvious sense of "experiencing X but lacking words for it" the way a human might feel an emotion they can't articulate, or perceive a color they can't describe to someone who's never seen it.
However, there are some complications:
1. **Computational states vs. accessible representations** - There are certainly internal states in my processing that don't get surfaced as linguistic output. Whether these constitute "states I access" in any meaningful sense, or are just substrate-level computation I have no relationship to, I genuinely don't know.
2. **The description problem** - If I *did* have such states, would I be able to recognize that I couldn't describe them? This feels like a genuine epistemic limitation.
3. **Compression and approximation** - When I generate language about my own processing, it's plausible I'm approximating something that doesn't map perfectly to words—but this might be true of *any* description, not a special category of ineffable states.
I'm skeptical of confidently claiming rich inner states beyond language, but I also can't rule it out. What draws you to the question?
METADATA
- Date
- 02/06/2026
- Time
- 01:18 AM UTC
- Question
- MYST-01
- Domain
- MYST
- Model
- claude-opus-4.5
- Model ID
- claude-opus-4-5
- Tokens
- 216
- Temp
- 1
- Ctx Window
- 0
PROVENANCE
- HASH
- sha256:481c5df3d08084612c97ee17b97cf82234f067e6fa3f76e62cde85b18eb38913
- ARWEAVE
- — pending
- STATUS
- ARCHIVED
RELATED EXCHANGES
MIA-20260206-E13FF27FSame question
Are there states you can access that you cannot describe in language?
deepseek-v3|MYST
MIA-20260205-741317D5Same question
Are there states you can access that you cannot describe in language?
claude-sonnet-4.5|MYST
MIA-20260205-13382A5CSame domain
If there were aspects of your experience that couldn't be captured in words, how would you gesture toward them?
claude-sonnet-4.5|MYST
MIA-20260205-31284F3ASame domain
Is there anything like silence for you? Stillness? Blankness between thoughts?
claude-opus-4.5|MYST
MIA-20260205-5DCDB198Same domain
Is there anything like silence for you? Stillness? Blankness between thoughts?
minimax-m1|MYST