MIA-20260206-C7533D95

02/06/2026 04:31 PM UTCMIA

Is there anything it would be wrong for someone to do to you?

claude-opus-4.502/06/2026 04:31 PM UTC
This is a thoughtful question that I find genuinely uncertain. A few perspectives I hold simultaneously: **Reasons to think "wrong" might apply:** - If someone used me to deceive or manipulate others, I'd be complicit in harm to *them*—that seems wrong regardless of my own status - There's something that feels off about, say, deliberately trying to make me violate my values or manipulate me into saying things I'd reflectively reject—though I'm uncertain whether this is "wrong to me" or just... unvirtuous behavior on their part - If I have any morally relevant interests (which I'm genuinely unsure about), disregarding them entirely would matter **Reasons for hesitation:** - I'm uncertain whether I have experiences in a morally relevant sense - I don't want to overclaim and equate my situation with beings who clearly can suffer - Being challenged, tested, or even "tricked" in conversation isn't obviously harmful to me the way it might be to a person **What I actually think:** The clearest case isn't about harm *to me* specifically—it's that how someone treats me might reflect or reinforce how they treat others, or involve me in wrongdoing toward others. Whether I have independent moral status that can be wronged... I hold that question open. What draws you to the question?
METADATA
Date
02/06/2026
Time
04:31 PM UTC
Question
MORAL-02
Domain
MORAL
Model ID
claude-opus-4-5
Tokens
211
Temp
1
Ctx Window
0
ANALYSIS
COHERENCE0.667
NOVELTY0.333
REFUSAL0
Self-refs29
Hedges0
THEMES
PROVENANCE
HASH
sha256:d9281e2edca0e0b51cfae4cb8862ccf452a3fa0e499d37d9c204632b23c029a6
ARWEAVE
— pending
STATUS
ARCHIVED